Cardiac Rehab: High Value, Low Usage
Although cardiac rehabilitation can be incredibly effective for older adults suffering from heart conditions or recovering from surgery, it’s vastly underused. Here’s what you should know to encourage your clients’ involvement.
Patients with heart issues often have a long road to recovery, but participating in cardiac rehabilitation can help speed up and stabilize the healing process. According to the American Heart Association (AHA), cardiac rehabilitation is a medically supervised program to help patients recover quickly and improve their overall physical, mental, and social functioning. Those who may benefit from this form of rehab include people who have had heart attacks, coronary artery disease, heart failure, cardiomyopathy, angioplasty and stents, chest pain, heart valve replacements, or heart transplants.
The goal of cardiac rehabilitation is to stabilize, slow, or even reverse the progression of cardiovascular disease, thereby reducing the risk of future problems. However, even though these types of programs have proven successful in guarding against future heart trouble, practitioners often fail to refer older patients to cardiac rehab. And there’s evidence that many older adult patients who are referred don’t attend as often as they should. More than one study has shown a severe disconnect in referral and participation rates, especially for older adults.
One study, published in the July 28, 2009, online edition of the Journal of the American College of Cardiology, found that only 56% of heart patients were referred for cardiac therapy. Specifically, researchers looked at data from 72,817 patients discharged from hospitals following heart attacks, angioplasty, or bypass surgery and found that only 40,974 of these patients (56%) were referred to cardiac rehab programs following their hospital stays. Older adults, especially those with a non–ST-segment elevation heart attack or those with additional medical conditions such as lung disease, were even less likely to be referred.
The reasons for the lack of referrals are manifold. “Barriers which may prevent referral into cardiac rehabilitation could include cost, lack of insurance coverage, time commitment, and distance from a cardiac rehabilitation center,” says study researcher Gregg C. Fonarow, MD, a professor of cardiology at UCLA. “Also, physician awareness about the benefits of cardiac rehabilitation appears to be lower compared to other interventions to treat patients with coronary artery disease.” Fonarow believes that increased awareness is needed to help doctors realize the clinical benefits of cardiac rehab and encourage them to prescribe it to more patients more often.
The Most to Gain
“The most important benefit is that people who do cardiac rehab live longer,” says the lead author of that study, Jose A. Suaya, MD, PhD, MBA, MPH, of Brandeis University. The study shows that patients with different clinical backgrounds (heart attacks, coronary bypass operations, congestive heart failure, etc), all had lower mortality rates when they participated in cardiac rehab. In fact, within a span of five years, mortality rates were 21% to 34% lower in older adult patients who participated in cardiac rehabilitation.
Suaya adds that cardiac rehab participants are more likely to have a better quality of life, too. “There are other studies that show these patients not only live longer but live better,” he says. “Patients have a much higher functional status after cardiac rehab. They’re not just better on the treadmill test but more able to function independently at home.”
There are also social benefits, adds coauthor Philip Ades, MD, a professor of medicine and director of cardiac rehabilitation and prevention at the University of Vermont College of Medicine. “A lot of older adults live alone, and a cardiac rehab program can be a social opportunity for these individuals to get out and interact with other people,” he says. “Isolation and depression can predict a bad outcome with the recovery process, but interacting with others and achieving that social component can be an added benefit of participating in such a program. Unfortunately, the group setting may also be a reason some older adults choose not to attend cardiac rehab. There are older patients that prefer to avoid group activity.”
Along with that social advantage is a psychological benefit. People who participate in rehabilitation programs tend to have less anxiety and overall better mental health. These benefits may be even greater for women with heart disease, who are more likely than men to suffer from depression. A recent five-year study funded by the National Institute of Nursing Research found that symptoms of depression among women with coronary heart disease were improved when they participated in a motivationally enhanced cardiac rehab program. It’s a bit of a catch-22 because women often lack the motivation to attend a cardiac rehab session, especially if they’re suffering from depression, says Theresa Beckie, PhD, RN, FAHA, lead study author and a professor at the University of South Florida College of Nursing. But her study found that cardiac rehabilitation programs tailored to the specific needs of women and their current levels of readiness to change may improve adherence to such programs and potentially improve outcomes.
The study looked at motivationally enhanced, women-only cardiac rehab vs. a traditional program and found that the depression scores for women participating in traditional cardiac rehab dropped from 16.5 to 14.3 in 12 weeks, while the scores in the augmented group dropped from 17.3 to 11. Clearly any cardiac rehab will help with depression, but there’s a more significant impact for women who seek out specialized programs suited to their needs. “Older adults, particularly women, have not been socialized to exercise and prescribing a routine can be very intimidating for them,” says Beckie. “A rehab program that uses motivational interviewing starts where the patient wants to start. It’s more of a collaborative effort than traditional rehab, which is very prescriptive and regimented.”
In terms of gender-specific groups, Beckie says this is likely more effective in encouraging regular attendance because women often don’t like to exercise in front of men. “They also garner a lot of social support from other women going through the same experience when they’re involved in a women-only group,” she adds. “Women are skilled at offering support to other women, and I know that’s something that increased attendance among those we studied.”
Too Old for Rehab?
There is no such thing as being too old for one of these programs. “There is no upper age limit for participation in cardiac rehabilitation,” affirms Fonarow. “Participation in contemporary, community-based cardiac rehabilitation programs is associated with reduced mortality and fewer recurrent myocardial infarctions in older adults.”
In addition, Ades says the number of patients who are too sick to participate in cardiac rehab is low and is by no means a major reason for the lack of attendance. “Probably about 10% of those who are candidates for rehab may not attend because they are truly too sick—it’s a small percentage,” he says. “That would include patients who suffer from things like end-stage cancer, dementia, or severe chronic diseases.”
He shares Fonarow’s belief that cardiac rehab is very safe. “What’s not safe is not doing cardiac rehab after a heart event,” Ades says. “There aren’t too many situations where it will make the person worse. There really are very few downsides.”
Physicians need to be held more accountable for their role in prescribing and encouraging participation in rehab, says Beckie. “They need to be referring every eligible patient and be held accountable when they don’t,” she says. “Primary care physicians are often the worst [in referring patients]. They, too, often assume that their older patients won’t benefit from rehab, but that’s not what data is telling us. They can benefit as much as anyone else, if not more.”
If it’s a matter of forgetting to provide the patient with this information, one solution is making referrals to cardiac rehab an automatic option for any patient who has had a heart-related medical condition or surgery. Fonarow says the use of systems, clinical decision support, and hospital discharge checklists, including referral to cardiac rehabilitation, can help ensure that eligible patients are automatically referred for rehab. Ades says a system like this is in place where he works. “When the nurse or physician does a discharge summary on the electronic medical record, it asks whether they want to refer the patient for cardiac rehab,” he explains. “Automating the process like this helps to make sure the doctor remembers. But even before we used an electronic system, we had discharge summaries that reminded the nurse or physician to refer eligible patients. The key is to have some sort of system in place so the physician does not have a chance to forget.”
Professionals who are educated about cardiac rehab can help encourage their patients and clients to be sure they get referrals. “If you’ve had a cardiac event or surgery and you weren’t referred for rehab, you should ask the doctor why not,” says Ades. “In many cases, you need to be your own advocate. If a patient was not given this information, it was not necessarily meant for that patient not to be referred for rehab. Doctors are busy and something like this could have merely fallen through the cracks if the hospital doesn’t have an efficient discharge system in place. That’s why it’s important for patients, their caregivers, or others who work with them to also be educated about rehab.”
Professionals who work with the aging population should also be sure they’re familiar with the cardiac rehabilitation programs in their area and should keep tabs on their clients’ progress. Communicate directly with those running the rehab programs to see how clients are performing and be knowledgeable about the dates and times clients are scheduled for sessions. Sometimes patients require extra encouragement or even a reminder about their appointment dates. These small efforts can help increase their participation.
Professionals can also take responsibility for ensuring any obstacles that may be in the way of their clients attending rehab are resolved. Are there transportation issues? Financial or insurance issues that need to be addressed? Does the patient simply not like the group setting format that many rehab programs use? Once the patient has the doctor’s referral, other professionals involved with that patient’s care can take responsibility for preventing anything that may stand in the way of regular attendance. Getting the doctor’s referral is only the first step.
Frequently, when patients put the effort into participating in regular sessions, they end up being the best “salespeople” for cardiac rehab, says Ades. “They go back and tell everyone that it really helped,” he notes. “In some cases, peers can be even more effective than a doctor telling their patient to go to rehab.”
Keeping this in mind, encourage your clients to be vocal about their positive experiences with rehab. Find out what they liked and help pass that information on to other clients. Sometimes diminishing that feeling of uncertainty about what to expect is enough to motivate patients to attend their sessions.
With the evidence from these recent studies, there’s no question that cardiac rehab is incredibly beneficial yet vastly underused. Because it can not only extend patients’ lives but also help improve their lives, it’s important that older adults and the professionals involved in their care begin to embrace and encourage participation in such programs.
— Lindsey Getz is a freelance writer based in Royersford, Pa.
With Cardiac Rehab, More Is Better
“We were not surprised that patients who attended more rehabilitation had better outcomes,” study author Bradley G. Hammill, MS, said in a statement about the article published in Circulation in December 2009. “We need to encourage physicians to recommend cardiac rehabilitation to eligible patients, and we need to encourage those patients to attend and stay with it.”
But while Medicare will pay for 36 cardiac rehabilitation sessions, about one half of those in the study attended only 24 or fewer, said Hammill, a senior biostatistician at the Center for Clinical and Genetic Economics at the Duke Clinical Research Institute in Durham, N.C.
Those who attended all 36 sessions had a 12% lower risk of heart attack and 14% lower risk of death than those who went to 24 sessions. The gap was even greater when compared with those who attended 12 sessions or only one session. The rehab programs emphasize education about heart disease, exercise, stress, nutrition, and medication use, among other things.
“Unfortunately, use of cardiac rehab is very low,” Hammill said. “Under 20% of those eligible ever go, and women and minorities go less often than white men. We need to promote cardiac rehab for everyone.”
— Source: American Heart Association
• Research shows patient attendance is low, with only 12.2% of those who are referred actually participating. Encourage and support attendance; point out that rehab patients not only live longer, but they have a better quality of life.
• Rehab also offers social and psychological benefits to many older adults.
• Supervised rehab is safe, even for the very old.
• Learn about the best cardiac rehab services available.